Renaissance Secretaries

Secret Writing: A History of Codes, Ciphers and Codebreaking

Course 1 · Chapter 4 · Renaissance Secretaries

Chapter 3 ended with a contest: designers hide the letter counts, analysts hunt for new fingerprints. In the Italian city-states of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries that contest became a profession. Rulers needed to talk to ambassadors far away, every courier could be robbed, and so secret writing moved from a hobby to a government office with salaried staff.

Why Italy, and Why Then

Renaissance Italy was a crowded neighbourhood of rival states, among them Venice, Milan, Florence and the Papal court in Rome. Each kept resident ambassadors in the others' capitals, and each ambassador's letters passed through hands the sender did not control. A letter might be copied at a border, in an inn or in a post office. Encipherment became routine, and with it came the first cipher secretaries: clerks whose job was to encipher outgoing letters and read incoming ones.

Key figures Leon Battista Alberti (1404 to 1472): Italian scholar and architect who wrote a short treatise on ciphers and described a cipher disk.
Cicco Simonetta (died 1480): secretary to the dukes of Milan, said to have written an early manual on breaking ciphers.
Giovanni Soro (active 1506 to 1544): Venetian cipher secretary with a reputation for reading other states' mail.
Not Yet Verified The names, dates and roles above, and the claim that Alberti described the first cipher disk, are written from general knowledge and were not checked against a source for this chapter. Treat them as pointers for your own search.

The Nomenclator: A Code and a Cipher Together

Chapter 1 separated codes (whole words replaced by symbols) from ciphers (letters replaced). The workhorse of Renaissance diplomacy was a hybrid called a nomenclator. It had two parts:

  • a cipher alphabet, often with several symbols for the vowels (homophones, Chapter 3);
  • a code list: symbols for common names, places and words (the Pope, Venice, "treaty"), plus nulls that mean nothing.

It was practical: names and titles were exactly the words an enemy most wanted, and one symbol replaced a long word. Early nomenclators were short, perhaps a few dozen entries, but over time they grew to hundreds or thousands as secretaries added words.

PartJobWeakness
Cipher alphabetSpell out anything not on the listStill falls to frequency analysis if used alone
Code listHide the names and words that matter mostFinite: a word not on the list must be spelled; one captured table exposes every coded word
HomophonesSeveral symbols for common letters, to flatten countsPairs and word shapes still leak
NullsMeaningless filler to break up patternsEasy to spot once the rest is solved
A tiny nomenclator code list (an invented example) 11 = KING 12 = POPE 13 = SHIP 14 = GOLD 15 = SEND Message: THE 13 ARRIVES AT DAWN; 15 14 TO 11 Spelled-out letters are left plain here for clarity; a real one would also cipher them.

Alberti's Cipher Disk

The big conceptual leap came from Alberti. His idea was a pair of concentric discs, the outer fixed and the inner movable, each carrying an alphabet. Turn the inner disc and you have a different substitution alphabet, a Caesar shift of any size. His crucial suggestion was to change the setting partway through the message, so that the same plain letter does not always become the same cipher letter. This is the first clear step toward polyalphabetic ciphers: many alphabets in one message.

The same word enciphered with one setting, then with two alternating settings Plain : E E E E Shift 3 : H H H H (every E becomes H) 3,5,3,5 : H J H J (the same E gives two different letters)

That last line is the point. Once a plain letter can become different cipher letters, simple letter counting stops working, because E no longer produces one dominant cipher letter. This is exactly the defence flagged at the end of Chapter 3. The full idea does not become popular for a century or more, and Chapter 5 follows it to its famous, and then broken, conclusion.

Not Yet Verified Historians describe Alberti's disk and his habit of switching the setting using special marker letters in the text, but the detail of how the marker scheme worked is not checked here. The simple "alternate two shifts" scheme in this chapter is a teaching model, not a faithful copy of his system.

The First Black Chambers

If every state enciphers, every state also wants to read the others' letters. Secret offices grew up to open, copy, read and reseal diplomatic mail, and to break the ciphers they found. These are the origin of the phrase black chamber, which later became the nickname for any such office.

  • Opening letters: seals could be lifted with a warmed blade and replaced convincingly, so the sender never knew.
  • Copying: a clerk copied the cipher text quickly and the letter went on its way, often only a few hours late.
  • Breaking: specialist secretaries used frequency analysis, probable words (an ambassador's letters usually begin with a greeting to the same master) and the weak spots of nomenclators.
Not Yet Verified Which office came first, and the phrase "black chamber" for the earliest ones, are reported in popular histories but I did not check a source. The mail-opening techniques above are the general picture rather than a documented step-by-step.

Why the Nomenclator Lasted

You might expect Alberti's disk to have swept the world at once. It did not. A multiple-alphabet cipher is slow to use by hand and a single slipped letter garbles the rest of the message. A nomenclator is fast, familiar and good enough against most opponents, so it stayed the standard in diplomacy for around three centuries. Convenience beat strength, a lesson that recurs in every era, including modern IT.

Try it yourself: read the nomenclator Using the code list in the box above (11 = KING, 12 = POPE, 13 = SHIP, 14 = GOLD, 15 = SEND), decipher:

THE 13 ARRIVES AT DAWN; 15 14 TO 11

What is the message, and which of the code words is the most valuable if intercepted?
Show the worked answer

Replace each number: 13 is SHIP, 15 is SEND, 14 is GOLD, 11 is KING. The message is THE SHIP ARRIVES AT DAWN; SEND GOLD TO KING. The words that matter, such as SHIP, GOLD and KING, are exactly the ones the nomenclator hides, which is why interceptors tried so hard to steal or reconstruct the code list.

Where This Leaves the Secret Writer

By 1600 secret writing was a state function with trained staff, a hybrid standard system and one great idea waiting to be exploited. The next chapter follows that idea to the cipher that people called unbreakable for about three centuries, and to the men who proved it was not.

Exercises

Exercise 1

A nomenclator has the code list 31 = AMBASSADOR, 32 = VENICE, 33 = TREATY, 34 = SECRET, 35 = DUKE. Decipher: 35 SENDS 34 33 TO 32. (a) What does it say? (b) Why is a captured code list worse for the sender than a captured cipher alphabet? (c) Name one weakness of the code list part.

Exercise 2

Use a two-setting disk: the first letter of the message is shifted forward by 3, the second by 5, the third by 3, and so on, counting letters only. Encipher MEET ME AT NOON. Notice what happens to the repeated letters.

Exercise 3

This message was enciphered with alternating shifts of 2 and 6 (starting with 2, counting letters only, not restarting at each word): VNG KPBQE NKCBGY CZ POINV. Decipher it, and explain why simple letter counting would not have found the key.

Quick Reference

  • Nomenclator: a cipher alphabet plus a code list of names and words, with nulls and homophones
  • Alberti's disk: two discs, one movable, giving a new alphabet each time the setting changes
  • Polyalphabetic: several cipher alphabets in one message, so one plain letter gives several cipher letters
  • Black chamber: a state office that opens, copies and reads other people's mail
  • Why nomenclators lasted: fast and familiar beat slow and strong
  • Check: the people, dates and roles, and how the first black chambers worked

Next chapter: The Unbreakable Cipher That Wasn't, with Vigenere and the breakers Babbage and Kasiski.