Exercise 3: sample answer Ciphertext: VNG KPBQE NKCBGY CZ POINV The shifts alternate 2, 6, 2, 6 ... and the count runs through the letters only, without restarting at each word. To decipher, shift each letter BACK by its amount. Letter positions: V1 N2 G3 | K4 P5 B6 Q7 E8 | N9 K10 C11 B12 G13 Y14 | C15 Z16 | P17 O18 I19 N20 V21 Odd positions use shift 2, even positions use shift 6: V-2=T, N-6=H, G-2=E, K-6=E, P-2=N, B-6=V, Q-2=O, E-6=Y, N-2=L, K-6=E, C-2=A, B-6=V, G-2=E, Y-6=S, C-2=A, Z-6=T, P-2=N, O-6=I, I-2=G, N-6=H, V-2=T Message: THE ENVOY LEAVES AT NIGHT Why counting fails: the same plain letter gets different cipher letters depending on its position (for example the E's in ENVOY, LEAVES and the others), so no single cipher letter dominates.