Beyond Steam
Railways: How the Iron Road Changed the World
Course 41 · Chapter 11 · Beyond Steam
Railways: How the Iron Road Changed the World 10 looked at the passenger's railway at its steam-age height. This chapter follows what replaced the steam locomotive, how trains became fast enough to rival aircraft, and why a network that seemed to be dying in the 1960s is growing again. As before, dates, counts and "firsts" are flagged "check".
Why Steam Gave Way
A steam locomotive is a mechanically simple but labour-hungry machine. It needs coal and water, a crew to shovel and fire, hours of preparation to raise steam, and frequent servicing. Only a small fraction of the energy in the coal reaches the wheels (check typical efficiency figures). The alternatives were diesel locomotives, which carry their own fuel and can start in minutes, and electric locomotives, which draw power from a wire or rail and keep the power station off the train. Diesel and electric traction cost less to run and maintain, can be driven by one person, and can run almost round the clock.
Diesel Takes Over
Early diesel locomotives appeared in the first decades of the twentieth century, first as small shunters and railcars. Large diesel locomotives became common after the Second World War, and in the United States the change was swift; by the late 1950s steam had been largely replaced on the main lines (check the dates and the leading builders). Britain, France, Germany and most other countries followed through the 1950s and 1960s, and steam was withdrawn from British Railways main-line service in 1968 (check). A key technical idea was the diesel-electric transmission: the diesel engine drives a generator, and the electricity turns motors on the axles. This solves the problem that an engine cannot easily start a heavy load from standstill through a plain gearbox.
Electrification
Electric trains are quiet, powerful and clean at the point of use. Power arrives by an overhead wire (a catenary) or a third rail beside the track. Electrification is expensive to build, since it needs masts, wires and substations along the whole route, so it pays only on busy lines. It was adopted early on suburban and underground railways, then on mountain lines and heavily used main lines. Countries differ in the voltage and system they chose, which created a new interoperability problem like the old gauge differences: a train may need to carry equipment for several supply systems to cross borders (check the main systems in use).
| Traction | Power source | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steam | Coal or oil boiling water | Simple, repairable, no infrastructure | Labour, inefficiency, slow to prepare |
| Diesel | Fuel carried on the train | Runs anywhere with track, quick to start | Fuel cost, emissions at point of use |
| Electric | Wire or third rail | Powerful, efficient, quiet | High build cost for the wires |
High-Speed Rail
Fast trains are as old as the railway, but the modern high-speed network began in Japan. The Shinkansen, or "bullet train", opened between Tokyo and Osaka on the Tokaido line on 1 October 1964, just before the Tokyo Olympics, with a top speed above 200 km/h (check the exact speed and the opening ceremony details). Its key idea was a dedicated line: new, straight, standard-gauge track kept apart from slower traffic, with no level crossings and trains designed for it. France followed with the TGV, its first line between Paris and Lyon opening in 1981 (check), and Germany, Spain, Italy and later China built large high-speed networks (check the current extent). High-speed trains are fast enough that, over a few hundred kilometres, the journey from city centre to city centre can beat flying once the airport transfers and waiting are counted.
Maglev and Other Experiments
Maglev trains use magnetic force to lift and drive the train without wheels touching a rail, removing friction and wear. A few lines carry passengers, notably the airport link at Shanghai, and Japan has built test lines for a faster maglev (check the speeds and the status of the projects). Maglev has not spread widely because it needs a completely new track that cannot connect to the existing network, which weakens the very network effect that made railways successful.
Decline and the Beeching Report
In many countries, rail's share of passenger and freight traffic fell sharply in the middle of the twentieth century as cars, lorries and aircraft grew. Branch lines in particular lost money. In Britain the government commissioned a report from Dr Richard Beeching, published in 1963 as The Reshaping of British Railways, which proposed closing many loss-making lines and stations. A large number of closures followed through the 1960s (check the mileage and the number of stations; figures vary). The report is still argued over: supporters say it faced financial reality, critics say it took too narrow an accounting view, ignoring the feeder value of branch lines to the main network and the loss to the communities concerned. Many countries had their own versions of this story, and some closed lines have since been rebuilt or reopened (check examples).
The Return to Favour
From the later twentieth century, concerns about congestion, emissions and energy use brought rail back into favour. Electric trains can run on low-carbon power, a train carries many people in little space, and high-speed lines have shown that rail can win travellers from short-haul flights. Governments invested in new lines, electrification and reopened routes, and commuter railways in big cities grew busier. The picture is mixed, though: new construction is costly and slow, and success depends on routes with enough passengers.
Exercises
Give three reasons why diesel and electric traction replaced steam, and explain why electrification is built mainly on busy lines.
Explain what made the Shinkansen different from earlier fast trains, and say why maglev has spread less widely than conventional high-speed rail.
Summarise the argument for and against the Beeching closures, then give a modern example of a service that looked unprofitable on its own but mattered to a wider system.
Quick Reference
- Diesel-electric: an engine drives a generator that powers axle motors
- Electrification: overhead wire or third rail, costly but efficient on busy lines
- Shinkansen: opened 1964, a dedicated high-speed line
- Maglev: magnetic levitation, needs entirely new track
- Beeching report: 1963, proposed mass closures; still debated