prize41-11, Exercise 3: The Beeching Argument Model answer (check the details): - For the closures: many branch lines and stations lost money as cars and lorries took traffic, and the 1963 report argued the railway could not afford to keep carrying them. - Against: critics say the report took a narrow accounting view, ignoring the feeder value of branch lines to the main network and the harm to communities left without a service. - Modern example (any sensible one): a small library branch, a rural bus route or a little-used open-source dependency may look costly or unused alone, yet feed users into, or quietly support, a larger system. Removing it can reduce the whole system's value. Care: closure totals vary between sources and should be checked.