Before the Railway

Railways: How the Iron Road Changed the World ๐Ÿ†

Course 41 ยท Chapter 1 ยท Before the Railway

A railway is a simple idea: give a wheeled vehicle a smooth, hard, guided track, and one horse can pull far more than it could on a mud road. Long before steam, miners in Britain and Europe had worked this out. This chapter looks at what moved goods and people before the railway: carts on bad roads, barges on canals, and the horse-drawn wagonways and tramways that were the railway's direct ancestors. It ends with the problem that steam power was about to solve. Dates and "firsts" below are flagged "check", because early railway history is full of rival claims.

The Problem: Bulk Goods and Bad Roads

Heavy, cheap cargo

Coal, stone, timber, grain and iron ore are heavy and low in value per tonne. Moving them even a few miles by cart could cost as much as the goods were worth, so such goods were used close to where they were dug or grown.

Roads of mud and ruts

Before the eighteenth century most British roads were poorly surfaced and maintained by local parishes. In wet weather loaded wagons sank to the axles, and horses tired quickly (check).

Friction

The central physics is rolling resistance. A wheel on soft ground digs a groove and must climb out of it continually. A wheel on a smooth hard rail rolls with a fraction of that resistance, which is why a horse on rails can haul several times the load (check the exact ratio, which varies by source).

The idea in one line Railways did not begin with the steam engine. They began with the track. The engine came later, and for roughly two centuries the "railway" was a horse-drawn affair serving mines and quarries.

Wagonways: the First Rails

Miners in central Europe used wooden rails and small trucks in the sixteenth century, and the idea reached Britain by the early seventeenth. One of the best-documented early British examples is the Wollaton Wagonway near Nottingham, laid around 1603 to 1604 to carry coal from pits to the River Trent, and usually credited to Huntingdon Beaumont (check). Wagonways spread across the coalfields of Northumberland and Durham, where coal was carried downhill from the pits to a river staithe, and loaded onto boats for London and the coast.

Feature (check each)Early wagonwayWhy it mattered
RailsTimber, later topped with iron strips to resist wearWood wore quickly, so iron was a major improvement
PowerHorses, often with gravity doing the work on loaded downhill runsOne horse could manage several wagons
GaugeSet by local practice, often around four to five feetThe seed of the gauge problem in Chapter 5
Owner and usersUsually a mine owner, carrying only his own coalA private road, not a public service

From Wood to Iron

The next steps were metallurgical. In the mid-eighteenth century ironmasters in Shropshire, at Coalbrookdale, began casting iron rails, with the first usually dated to the 1760s (check). Cast iron is hard but brittle, so it was later replaced by wrought iron, which could be rolled into longer, stronger rails. Two track designs competed: the plateway, with L-shaped plates guiding flat-wheeled wagons, and the edge rail, where the wheel itself has a flange that hooks over the rail. The edge rail won, and is the system used by railways today.

Track type (check)Where the guide isOutcome
PlatewayOn the rail (an upright lip)Used on many early tramways; mixed with ordinary roads easily, but lost out
Edge railOn the wheel (a flange)Became the standard, as it suits fast, heavy trains

Tramways and the First Public Lines

Two early developments blur the line between a private mine track and a public railway. The Middleton Railway near Leeds is usually described as the first railway authorised by an Act of Parliament, in the 1750s, to carry coal into Leeds (check whether 1757 or 1758). The Surrey Iron Railway, authorised in 1801 and opened in 1803 between Wandsworth and Croydon, is often called the first public railway, because anyone could use the track on payment of tolls with their own horses and wagons (check, as the claim is often qualified). That model, a public track open to many carriers rather than one operator's trains, is the opposite of how main-line railways later worked.

The Competition: Turnpikes and Canals

Transport (check each)StrengthWeakness
Turnpike roadsBetter surfaces, paid for by tolls through turnpike trusts from the early eighteenth centuryStill slow and expensive for heavy loads; weather dependent
CanalsOne horse can tow a heavy barge; cheap for bulk goods. The Bridgewater Canal, opened in 1761 to carry coal to Manchester, started the canal boomSlow, closed by ice and drought, hard to build over hills, and needs locks (see How Canals and Locks Work)
Coastal shippingThe main route for bulk goods such as coal to LondonLimited to coasts, and at the mercy of wind and tide
Wagonways and tramwaysCheap per tonne-mile on a short fixed routeShort, local, horse-powered, and not yet a network
Did you know By the 1790s Britain was in the middle of "canal mania", a speculative boom in building canals. The railways of the 1840s (Chapter 4) repeated the pattern on a larger scale, and many canals were bought by railway companies and left to decline (check).

The Missing Piece: Power

By about 1800 Britain had good rails for short routes, canals for bulk goods and turnpikes for coaches. What it lacked was a source of power that could move heavy loads faster than a horse, over any route, in any weather. Horses must be fed, rested and replaced, and a large share of the cost of a horse-drawn line was the horses. Stationary steam engines already pumped mines and drove mills, and the question was whether an engine could be put on wheels. Chapter 2 follows that story.

Modern parallel A wagonway is like a private network: a company builds its own link between its own sites, with its own rules. The big step, later, is connecting such networks into a public system that follows common standards, as the early private computer networks were later joined to form the internet. The first lesson of railways is that a link is useful, but a network is transformative.
Watch out "The first railway" depends on how the question is asked: the first track, the first public track, the first authorised by Parliament, the first with a steam locomotive, or the first to carry fare-paying passengers on a timetable. Each has a different answer. Whenever a source says "the first", ask which first it means.
Not Yet Verified A web search for this chapter agrees with the broad outline: the Wollaton Wagonway of about 1603 to 1604 is commonly described as an early British wagonway; the Middleton Railway is commonly described as the first authorised by Act of Parliament (sources differ between 1757 and 1758); and the Surrey Iron Railway opened in 1803 after an Act of 1801, though its "first public railway" title is often qualified. The dates of cast-iron rails, the Bridgewater Canal and the load ratios for horses on rails come from general knowledge and have not been checked against primary sources; treat every "(check)" accordingly.

Exercises

Exercise 1

In your own words, explain why a horse can pull far more on a rail than on a mud road, and say why the wagonways first appeared at mines rather than in towns.

Exercise 2

Choose three of the "firsts" mentioned in this chapter and, for each, state exactly what is being claimed to be first, and one reason a historian might dispute it.

Exercise 3

Compare canals and horse-drawn tramways for moving coal 20 miles in about 1790. List two advantages and two disadvantages of each, and say which you would build and why.

Coming up Chapter 2 follows the engine: from Newcomen and Watt to high-pressure steam, Trevithick and the first locomotives, and a plain-language look at how a steam locomotive works.

Quick Reference

  • Core idea: a smooth guided track cuts friction, so animals can haul much more
  • Early lines: Wollaton Wagonway (c. 1603-04), Middleton Railway (1750s), Surrey Iron Railway (1803)
  • Track: timber, then cast and wrought iron; plateway lost to edge rail
  • Rivals: turnpike roads, canals (Bridgewater, 1761), coastal shipping
  • Missing piece: a power source better than the horse