Exercise 1: Why Programs A and C Are Mathematically Identical — Possible Solution ==================================================================================== The disease is expected to affect 600 people in total, in both framings. Program A states that 200 people will be saved for certain. If 200 of 600 people are saved, the remaining 600 - 200 = 400 people are not saved - meaning they die. Program C states that 400 people will die for certain. If 400 of 600 people die, the remaining 600 - 400 = 200 people do not die - meaning they are saved. Both programs therefore describe the exact same real-world outcome: 200 people survive, and 400 people do not. The only difference between "Program A: 200 saved" and "Program C: 400 die" is which half of the same fixed total (600 people) the sentence chooses to describe - whether it names the surviving group or the group that doesn't survive. The underlying reality being described - who lives and who dies - is identical in both statements; only the words chosen to express it differ. ANSWER: Program A (200 saved) and Program C (400 die) both describe an identical real outcome out of 600 total people: 200 survive and 400 do not. Since 600 - 200 = 400, and 600 - 400 = 200, the two programs simply describe opposite halves of the exact same fixed group - the actual result is the same regardless of which half is named. WHY THIS WORKS AS AN ANSWER ------------------------------ This works through the actual arithmetic connecting the two framings, proving mathematical equivalence directly rather than only asserting that the two programs are "the same."