QUANTUM PHYSICS FUNDAMENTALS - Chapter 6, Exercise 1 Solution ========================================================== Minimum Momentum Uncertainty for a Proton in a Nucleus PROBLEM ------- A proton is confined to a region with position uncertainty Delta x = 2 x 10^-15 m (roughly the size of an atomic nucleus). Calculate the minimum possible uncertainty in its momentum. SOLUTION -------- Using the real, rigorous uncertainty relation: Delta p >= hbar / (2 Delta x) Substituting hbar = 1.0546 x 10^-34 J.s and Delta x = 2 x 10^-15 m: Delta p >= (1.0546 x 10^-34) / (2 x 2 x 10^-15) Delta p >= (1.0546 x 10^-34) / (4 x 10^-15) Delta p >= 2.6365 x 10^-20 kg.m/s ANSWER: The minimum possible uncertainty in the proton's momentum is approximately 2.64 x 10^-20 kg.m/s. ---- WHY THIS WORKS AS AN ANSWER This result is roughly 100,000 times larger than the chapter's own electron-in-an-atom example (5.27 x 10^-25 kg.m/s), even though the proton's own confinement region (2 x 10^-15 m, a nucleus) is much SMALLER than the electron's (1 x 10^-10 m, an atom). This is a real, direct illustration of the inverse relationship in the uncertainty principle: confining a particle to a smaller region of space (smaller Delta x) necessarily forces a genuinely larger minimum uncertainty in its momentum (larger Delta p), regardless of the particle's own mass. This same real relationship is part of why protons and neutrons confined within an atomic nucleus carry substantial real kinetic energy even at a temperature of absolute zero - a genuine, physical consequence of the uncertainty principle, not a measurement limitation.