CLASSICAL MECHANICS & THERMODYNAMICS - Chapter 7, Exercise 2 Solution ========================================================== Applying the Zeroth Law Without Direct Contact PROBLEM ------- Three metal blocks, A, B, and C, are tested with a thermometer. Block A and Block C both read exactly 25 degrees Celsius on the thermometer. Using the Zeroth Law, what can you conclude about the thermal relationship between Block A and Block C directly, without ever placing them in contact with each other? SOLUTION -------- The thermometer itself is the "third system" referred to in the Zeroth Law. When the thermometer is placed in contact with Block A and reaches thermal equilibrium with it (shown by a steady reading of 25 degrees Celsius), the thermometer and Block A are in thermal equilibrium with each other. The same is separately true for the thermometer and Block C, which also brings the thermometer to equilibrium at 25 degrees Celsius. The Zeroth Law states that if two systems (here, Block A and Block C) are each separately in thermal equilibrium with a third system (the thermometer), then Block A and Block C must be in thermal equilibrium with each other as well. ANSWER: Block A and Block C are in thermal equilibrium with each other - meaning if they were placed in direct contact, no net heat would flow between them - even though they were never actually brought into contact with one another. This can be concluded purely from each one separately reaching equilibrium with the same thermometer. ---- WHY THIS WORKS AS AN ANSWER This is exactly the real-world justification for why a thermometer works as a measuring instrument at all: it lets you compare the temperatures of two objects indirectly, through a shared third object, rather than needing to physically place every pair of objects you want to compare into direct contact with each other. Without the Zeroth Law's guarantee, a matching thermometer reading on two different objects would tell you nothing reliable about how those two objects would behave if you actually put them together.