ASTRONOMY FUNDAMENTALS - Chapter 3, Exercise 2 Solution ========================================================== How Mass and Radius Each Affect Escape Velocity PROBLEM ------- Using v = sqrt(2GM/r), explain what happens to escape velocity if a planet's mass doubles while its radius stays the same, versus what happens if its radius doubles while its mass stays the same. Which change increases escape velocity, and which decreases it? SOLUTION -------- Case 1: Mass doubles, radius stays the same (M -> 2M, r unchanged) v_new = sqrt(2G(2M)/r) = sqrt(2 x (2GM/r)) = sqrt(2) x sqrt(2GM/r) v_new = sqrt(2) x v_original v_new ≈ 1.41 x v_original Escape velocity INCREASES, by a factor of the square root of 2 (about 41% higher). Case 2: Radius doubles, mass stays the same (M unchanged, r -> 2r) v_new = sqrt(2GM/(2r)) = sqrt((1/2) x (2GM/r)) = sqrt(1/2) x sqrt(2GM/r) v_new = v_original / sqrt(2) v_new ≈ 0.71 x v_original Escape velocity DECREASES, to about 71% of its original value. ANSWER: Doubling the mass increases escape velocity (by a factor of sqrt(2)); doubling the radius decreases escape velocity (by a factor of 1/sqrt(2)). ---- WHY THIS WORKS AS AN ANSWER Mass sits in the numerator of the formula, so increasing it directly increases escape velocity - a more massive body has stronger gravity to escape from, requiring more speed. Radius sits in the denominator, so increasing it decreases escape velocity - a larger radius means the surface is farther from the body's own center of mass, where gravity is weaker (gravity falls off with the square of distance), so less speed is needed to escape from that more distant starting point. Because the formula takes a square root of the whole expression, mass and radius don't affect escape velocity by the same simple ratio they themselves changed by - doubling either one changes escape velocity by a factor of sqrt(2), not a factor of 2, since the square root "compresses" the effect of whatever is inside it.