Chinese Political History II: Chapter 5, Exercise 3 — Possible Solution ======================================================================= TASK Rewrite "WTO entry cost the US a million jobs" as an accurate statement. PROBLEMS 1. "Cost": it treats a correlation with imports as a cause and a net loss. 2. "A million jobs": the source says about a million manufacturing jobs were lost to import competition between 1999 and 2011, an estimate. 3. "WTO entry": the period starts in 1999, two years before accession on 11 December 2001, and imports depend on many factors. 4. It omits the offsetting estimate: Chinese imports lowered US manufactured-goods prices by about 7.6 percent from 2000 to 2006. REWRITE "One summary estimates that about a million US manufacturing jobs were lost to import competition from China between 1999 and 2011, and that Chinese imports lowered US manufactured-goods prices by about 7.6 percent between 2000 and 2006. These are estimates from a single source, and the researchers behind such work have revised the net picture (see Economics Fundamentals 9)." RULE Give the figure, the period, the source, and the offsetting effect, and do not turn an estimate into a cause.