MUSIC THEORY FUNDAMENTALS - Chapter 10, Exercise 1 Solution ========================================================== Rewriting the Ending as a Deceptive Cadence PROBLEM ------- Rewrite this chapter's own consequent phrase (bars 5-8) so that it ends with a real deceptive cadence instead of a perfect authentic cadence - state which chord bar 8 would need to become, and explain your reasoning using Chapter 8's own material. SOLUTION -------- The capstone's own current bar 8 is C major (I), preceded by G major (V) in bar 7 - a perfect authentic cadence (V -> I). Chapter 8's own cadence table defines a deceptive cadence as V resolving to vi instead of I. In C major, per Chapter 7's own diatonic chord set, vi is A minor. Rewritten bars 7-8: Bar 7: G major (V) - unchanged Bar 8: A minor (vi) - changed from C major (I) ANSWER: Bar 8 would need to become A minor (vi) instead of C major (I), producing the motion V -> vi (G major to A minor) instead of V -> I. ---- WHY THIS WORKS AS AN ANSWER This is a direct substitution using Chapter 8's own stated deceptive- cadence rule. The rewritten ending would still feel harmonically prepared by the same G major (V) chord as the original, but the actual arrival on A minor rather than C major would create the real "hanging," surprised sensation Chapter 8 described - the listener's ear, primed for resolution to the tonic, is instead redirected somewhere related but genuinely unexpected.