Exercise 2: Gate Count for xy + x'y, Unsimplified vs. Simplified — Possible Solution ==================================================================== GIVEN ------------------------------ Unsimplified: f(x,y) = xy + x'y Simplified (from Chapter 5 Exercise 1): f(x,y) = y STEP 1: DESCRIBE THE UNSIMPLIFIED CIRCUIT, GATE BY GATE ------------------------------ - One NOT gate, producing x' from x - One AND gate, computing xy (from the raw inputs x and y) - One AND gate, computing x'y (from x' and y) - One OR gate, combining xy and x'y into the final output Gate count: 1 NOT + 2 AND + 1 OR = 4 gates total STEP 2: DESCRIBE THE SIMPLIFIED CIRCUIT ------------------------------ The simplified expression is just y - the output IS one of the original inputs, wired straight through with no gates at all needed in between. Gate count: 0 gates RESULT ------------------------------ Unsimplified circuit: 4 gates (1 NOT, 2 AND, 1 OR) Simplified circuit: 0 gates (a direct wire from input y to output) This is the most extreme possible case of Chapter 6's own gate-count-reduction principle - simplification didn't just make the circuit smaller, it eliminated the need for a circuit at all. WHY THIS WORKS AS AN ANSWER ------------------------------ The unsimplified circuit's gate count is built up explicitly, gate by gate, matching how the raw Boolean expression xy + x'y would actually need to be wired (including the NOT gate its own x' term requires), and the comparison against the zero-gate simplified version makes explicit just how large a reduction is possible when an entire variable drops out during simplification.