Exercise 1: sample answer Cipher text: H X L Q A E D P R M Crib: MEET Rule: a position is impossible if any crib letter lines up with the same cipher letter. Position 0: M/H, E/X, E/L, T/Q - no clash, possible Position 1: M/X, E/L, E/Q, T/A - no clash, possible Position 2: M/L, E/Q, E/A, T/E - no clash, possible Position 3: M/Q, E/A, E/E - clash, impossible Position 4: M/A, E/E - clash, impossible Position 5: M/E, E/D, E/P, T/R - no clash, possible Position 6: M/D, E/P, E/R, T/M - no clash, possible Impossible positions: 3 and 4. Remaining positions: 5 (0, 1, 2, 5 and 6).