Exercise 3: sample answer Cipher text letters only: VHXMIGISXPDLVHXIOEFAGFTAGSAKPLVHXPEQVMHTNBPG (a) VHX first appears at position 0 and again at position 12. The gap is 12 letters. (b) VHX appears a third time at position 30, so the gaps are 12 (first to second), 18 (second to third) and 30 (first to third). The key length must divide all of them. The common factors are 2, 3 and 6, so the key is probably 3 or 6 letters long. A length of 3 is the simplest guess, and it is the right one here. (c) Keyword CAT = shifts 2, 0, 19, repeating. Subtract each from the cipher letter. VHX -> THE, MIGI -> KING, SXPDL -> SENDS, VHX -> THE, IOEF -> GOLD, AGF -> AND, TAG -> THE, SAKPL -> SHIPS, VHX -> THE, PEQV -> NEXT, MHTNBPG -> MORNING Message: THE KING SENDS THE GOLD AND THE SHIPS THE NEXT MORNING