Exercise 2: sample answer (a) Split SHNEEONLWDPX into columns of three: SHN, EEO, NLW, DPX. Write them as columns: S E N D H E L P N O W X Reading across the rows gives SENDHELPNOWX, which is SEND HELP NOW followed by the padding letter X. (b) With 4 letters per turn the columns are SHNE, EONL, WDPX, giving the rows: S E W H O D N N P E L X Reading across gives SEWHODNNPELX, which is gibberish. The rod's thickness is the key: the wrong rod gives no readable text. But a spy has only a few sensible rod sizes to try, so a scytale is weak once the method is known.