Exercise 3: sample answer Message: OPEN SESAME, shift 7 (add 7 to each letter). O -> V, P -> W, E -> L, N -> U S -> Z, E -> L, S -> Z, A -> H, M -> T, E -> L Puzzle: VWLU ZLZHTL Sample hint: "Two words from a folk tale about a cave full of treasure; the cipher is a simple shift." Weakness that cracks it without the hint: there are only 25 possible shifts, so a stranger can try them all in a minute. Frequency analysis would also work with a longer message, since a shift keeps the letter pattern of the language, only moved along the alphabet (Chapters 2 and 3). The kept word break makes it easier still.