Exercise 2: sample answer (a) Most likely a simple substitution cipher. One letter stands out at about 12 percent, like E in English, and the rest keep an uneven spread. The pattern of the language shows through, so frequency analysis (Chapter 3) applies. (b) Most likely a random one-time key. With 26 letters, a perfectly even spread is about 3.8 percent each, so "about 4 each with no pattern" means the text has no language statistics left to find. That is the sign of a truly random key used once (Chapter 10). Nothing can be broken without the key. (c) Most likely a Vigenere cipher with a short key. Mixing several shifts flattens the letter counts, but because the key repeats, the same plaintext groups sometimes line up with the same part of the key and produce the same ciphertext groups. The distances between repeats tend to be multiples of the key length, which is how Babbage and Kasiski attacked it (Chapter 5).