prize41-4, Exercise 3: Engineer, Contractor, Navvy Model answer (check the details): - Engineer: surveyed the route, designed the cuttings, embankments, bridges and tunnels, and supervised the quality of the work, but did not usually employ the labour. - Contractor: agreed a price for a section of line, hired and paid the gangs and managed materials and horses, and carried the financial risk of the job. - Navvy: did the physical digging, hauling and building by hand, moving from site to site, in dangerous conditions and often living in temporary camps. A conflict between finance and engineering: engineers wanted gentle gradients, long cuttings, tunnels and sound structures, while promoters needed a low capital figure to win investors and Parliament. Estimates were often optimistic, so costs overran and a company that had run out of money could not easily change the route its Act fixed. A modern example: a software project sold on an optimistic estimate, where engineers want time for testing and sound design and management wants the lowest quote; or a large IT rollout that runs over budget and is trimmed to fit. Care: roles overlapped in practice, and some engineers also acted as contractors or promoters, so the table is a simplification.