Safety and Signals
Railways: How the Iron Road Changed the World
Course 41 · Chapter 9 · Safety and Signals
Railways: How the Iron Road Changed the World 8 followed the lines across whole continents. Once trains were fast, heavy and frequent, a new problem grew: how to stop them hitting each other. This chapter looks at how signalling, interlocking and brakes developed, and how disasters often forced the changes. As before, dates, counts and "firsts" are flagged "check".
Why Trains Are Hard to Keep Apart
A train cannot swerve, and a heavy train needs a long distance to stop, often far more than the driver can see ahead. So safety cannot rely on the driver spotting trouble. It has to come from a system: rules, signals and equipment that keep each train in its own stretch of track. Early railways used a crude method called the time interval system: a train was allowed to leave a station a set number of minutes after the one before (check the typical intervals). It assumed the earlier train had kept moving. If it broke down, the following train could run into it.
The Block System
The answer was the block system. The line is divided into sections, called blocks, and only one train may be in a block at a time. A signaller at each end of a block uses the electric telegraph to ask permission and to report that the train has left (see Railways: How the Iron Road Changed the World 6 for how the telegraph became part of the railway). A signal then tells the driver whether the next block is clear. The rule changes the safety question from "how long ago did the last train leave?" to "is the last train actually out of the section?" Block working spread gradually in Britain from the 1840s and 1850s, and it was made compulsory by law only later (check the dates and the pioneers).
| System | Rule | Weakness |
|---|---|---|
| Time interval | Leave a set time after the previous train | A stopped train is invisible to the next one |
| Block system | One train per section; confirm clear by telegraph | Relies on people following the procedure correctly |
| Interlocked block | Signals, points and block instruments linked mechanically or electrically | Costly to install; faults must fail safe |
Interlocking
Even with blocks, a signaller could make a deadly mistake, such as setting the points for one route while showing a clear signal for another. Interlocking links the levers so that conflicting moves are physically impossible: for example, a signal cannot be pulled off to clear unless the points are set and locked in the right position, and the points cannot be moved while the signal shows clear. The idea took shape in the 1850s and was refined over following decades (check the early inventors and dates). Interlocking turns a rule that people must remember into a constraint the equipment enforces.
Brakes That Work on Every Carriage
Early trains were braked by the locomotive and by brakemen who applied handbrakes on individual vehicles, which was slow and unreliable. The next step was the continuous brake, controlled by the driver and acting on every vehicle of the train. The key refinement was making the brake automatic: held off by vacuum or compressed air, so that if the train breaks in two or a pipe fails, the loss of pressure applies the brakes by itself. The compressed-air version is associated with George Westinghouse in the United States, and the vacuum form was widely used in Britain (check the inventors and dates). A brake that fails safe is one of the great design ideas of railway engineering.
Accidents That Changed the Rules
Safety rules were often written after the event. The best-known British example is the Armagh rail disaster of 12 June 1889 in Ireland, then part of the United Kingdom. An excursion train carrying Sunday school children stalled on a hill, the crew split the train to cope, and the rear part ran back down the slope into a following train. About 80 people died, many of them children (check the exact figures). The coaches had only a simple brake worked by the driver, not an automatic continuous brake, so the detached portion had no effective brakes. The public outcry helped drive the Regulation of Railways Act 1889, which allowed the Board of Trade to require block signalling with interlocking and automatic continuous brakes on passenger trains (check the details and its limits, which covered passenger trains only).
Other accidents each left their mark, on matters such as signal design, track and bridge strength, and communications, and many countries built official inspection bodies and accident investigations on the same lesson: find the cause, then change the rule or the equipment (check examples such as the Abbots Ripton, Tay Bridge and Quintinshill accidents, and what each changed).
Exercises
Explain the difference between the time interval system and the block system, and say why the block system is safer.
Describe what interlocking does and what an "automatic" continuous brake does, and explain what the two have in common in terms of design.
Using the Armagh disaster as your example, explain how an accident can lead to a change in law, and give a modern parallel from a field you know.
Quick Reference
- Time interval: separation by minutes, which fails if a train stops
- Block system: one train per section, confirmed by telegraph
- Interlocking: signals and points linked so conflicts cannot occur
- Automatic continuous brake: applies itself if pressure is lost
- Armagh, 1889: led to the Regulation of Railways Act 1889