Absolute Dating II: Potassium-Argon & Other Radiometric Clocks

Prehistoric Times: How Much Do We Know, and How?

Chapter 4 · Absolute Dating II: Potassium-Argon & Other Radiometric Clocks

Radiocarbon dating runs out of atoms to count somewhere around 50,000 years. Most of human evolution happened well before that ceiling. This chapter covers the real clock that picks up where Chapter 3 leaves off — and a genuine, real controversy that shows exactly what can go wrong when a single method's own results go unchecked.

A Different Clock, Ticking Inside the Rock Itself

Potassium-argon (K-Ar) dating works on the same basic principle as radiocarbon — a radioactive "parent" isotope decays into a stable "daughter" isotope at a fixed, known rate — but it measures something genuinely different. Radiocarbon tracks the moment an organism died. K-Ar tracks the moment a volcanic rock cooled and solidified, trapping argon gas inside its own mineral crystals as it hardens. Measure the ratio of trapped argon-40 to remaining potassium-40, and you get a real age for when that rock last cooled.

What's Actually Being Dated K-Ar dating almost never dates a fossil directly — bone isn't a K-Ar-datable mineral. What it dates is a volcanic ash or lava layer found above and below a fossil in the same real stratigraphic sequence (Chapter 2), bracketing the fossil's own real age between two independently measured dates.

The Real Numbers

Potassium-40's own real half-life is roughly 1.248 billion years — genuinely enormous compared to carbon-14's 5,730 years. That long half-life makes K-Ar dating most reliable for rocks and minerals older than about 100,000 years, with no real practical upper limit at all; it has been used to date material billions of years old. The method works on common rock-forming minerals — feldspars, micas, clay minerals, volcanic ash (tephra), and evaporites — and has been central to dating hominin fossil sites across East Africa, where volcanic activity regularly deposited fresh ash layers.

MethodHalf-LifeReal Effective RangeWhat It Dates
Radiocarbon (Ch. 3)~5,730 yearsUp to ~50,000–75,000 yearsOrganic material — wood, bone, shell, charcoal
Potassium-Argon~1.248 billion yearsBeyond ~100,000 years, essentially no upper limitVolcanic rock and ash — never the fossil itself
An Honest Gap Between the Two Roughly between 50,000 and 100,000 years, radiocarbon is running low on measurable atoms and K-Ar isn't yet at its own most reliable range — a genuine, real gap neither method covers especially well on its own. Chapter 7 covers a real, worked case (Jebel Irhoud) where a third method, thermoluminescence, was needed to date material sitting right in that gap.

A Real Controversy: The KBS Tuff

In 1969–1970, geochronologists Frank Fitch and Jack Miller dated a volcanic ash layer at Koobi Fora, Kenya — the "KBS Tuff" — to roughly 2.61 million years old, using argon-based dating. That real date mattered enormously: it would have made the hominin fossils found near it, including the skull KNM-ER 1470, dramatically older than expected.

The result didn't hold up. Real, independent attempts to reproduce the date came back wildly inconsistent — anywhere from under 1 million to over 220 million years. Separately, paleontologists Vincent Maglio and Basil Cooke examined the real fossil pig teeth found in the same layers and concluded, on entirely different biological grounds, that the site was closer to 2 million years old. The 2.61-million-year date also didn't line up cleanly with the stratigraphy of nearby deposits.

Geochronologists Garniss Curtis and Thure Cerling at Berkeley eventually found the real, concrete cause: the original samples had actually come from two separate volcanic tuffs, mixed together and dated as one. Once properly separated, the real ages worked out to roughly 1.8 and 1.6 million years — since confirmed by independent potassium-argon dating (Ian McDougall) and by an entirely different method, fission-track dating (Andy Gleadow). The KBS Tuff's own currently accepted age is 1.869 ± 0.021 million years.

Why This Story Belongs Here The KBS Tuff wasn't resolved by one lab simply insisting it was right. It was resolved by real fossil evidence, real stratigraphic evidence, and two entirely independent radiometric methods all converging on the same corrected number. That convergence — not any single measurement — is what real scientific confidence in a prehistoric date actually looks like.

A Real Refinement: Argon-Argon Dating

Classic K-Ar dating has a real, practical weakness: it requires splitting a sample in two, measuring potassium in one half and argon in the other — introducing extra room for measurement error between the two separate pieces. Physicist Grenville Turner developed a real refinement, argon-argon (⁴⁰Ar/³⁹Ar) dating, which irradiates a single sample with neutrons to convert some of its stable potassium into a measurable form of argon — letting the entire age be calculated from one sample, with one measurement. It was argon-argon dating, applied against an irradiated reference standard, that ultimately delivered the KBS Tuff's own final, corrected age above.

Reflect

Question 1 K-Ar dating almost always dates the rock around a fossil, not the fossil itself. What real assumption does "bracketing" a fossil's age between two dated layers depend on, and what could go wrong with it?
Question 2 The KBS Tuff's original 2.61-million-year date was eventually overturned by fossil evidence, stratigraphic evidence, and two independent radiometric methods — not by one lab re-running its own original test. Why might disagreement between genuinely different lines of evidence be more useful than a single method simply repeating itself?
Question 3 Argon-argon dating fixed a real, practical weakness in the original K-Ar method (splitting one sample into two). What does the existence of a "generation two" version of a dating method suggest about treating any single dating technique as a permanently finished tool?

Chapter 4 Quick Reference

  • K-Ar dating — dates a volcanic rock's own cooling event, not an organism's death
  • Half-life — potassium-40, ~1.248 billion years; reliable beyond ~100,000 years, with no real practical upper limit
  • Bracketing — a fossil's age is inferred from dated ash/lava layers above and below it, not measured directly
  • The KBS Tuff — an initial 2.61-million-year date (1969–70), overturned by fossil, stratigraphic, and multi-method radiometric evidence, settling at 1.869 ± 0.021 million years
  • Argon-argon dating — Grenville Turner's real single-sample refinement of classic K-Ar, used to resolve the KBS Tuff controversy
  • An honest gap — roughly 50,000–100,000 years sits between radiocarbon's ceiling and K-Ar's own most reliable range